Color in painting starts as a material, and for most of history it was a difficult one. The best blue could cost more than gold, and some greens and yellows darkened within a few years of being painted.
Twelve paintings show what painters made of those materials, from a sky flaking off a chapel wall in Padua to a green curtain that sank into black for centuries.

Cool Stories About Art is a newsletter to learn art the fun way.
Join 200,000+ readers and get:
10 new art stories / month
The entire archive of content (140+ articles)
Comment, ask questions, and chat with other readers
How These Were Chosen
Before a color is red or blue, it is a powder made from a stone, a mineral, an earth or a plant, then bound in egg, glue or oil. Some of those powders were rare and costly. Others would not hold on wet plaster, or faded and darkened with time.
Once it is on the wall or the canvas, that powder decides where the eye lands first. A color can also depart from nature on purpose, and nothing stops a painter from making a river pink or a horse blue.
Every painting was chosen because its story turns on color, on how the painter handled it or on what became of the pigment later. Pictures admired only for being bright were left out. The oldest of the twelve is a sky painted on a chapel wall in Padua.
12. Giotto, Lamentation (c. 1305)
Above the dead Christ, whose head rests in his mother's hands, angels twist in grief across a blue sky. Up close, that blue is not whole. In places it has come away, and patches of gray or dark red show through.
The scene is a Lamentation, the mourning over Christ's body after the Crucifixion. The Florentine painter Giotto made it around 1305 for Enrico Scrovegni, a banker of Padua, in the chapel he had built next to his palace. It is one episode in a long cycle on the life of Christ that covers the chapel walls.
For a long time, the blue of that sky was taken for lapis lazuli, the stone that gave ultramarine, the most expensive pigment of the Middle Ages. The restoration of 2001 to 2002 found something else. Giotto had used azurite, a copper mineral that was far more common and far cheaper.
The cheaper blue came with a problem. In true fresco, the paint goes onto the wall while the lime plaster is still wet, and painters of Giotto's time held that azurite could not survive in it.
So Giotto painted the sky in two stages. First, while the plaster was wet, he laid in the areas meant to be blue with a base of gray or dark red, which the blue would later cover. Once the plaster had dried, he brushed the azurite over that base, bound with animal glue or egg.
That blue sits on the wall rather than in it, and this is why it has flaked. The gray and dark red patches seen up close are the first coat, uncovered wherever the azurite has fallen away.
At a Glance
Artist: Giotto di Bondone (about 1267 to 1337)
Painted: About 1305
Medium: Fresco, with the blue added on dry plaster
Size: About 200 × 185 cm (79 × 73 in)
Where to see it: Scrovegni Chapel, Musei Civici, Padua
11. Jan van Eyck, The Arnolfini Portrait (1434)
A long green dress, lined with white fur and gathered up in front of the woman who wears it, fills much of the Arnolfini Portrait. Beneath it, a blue underdress shows only at her forearms. Jan van Eyck, the Flemish painter who worked in Bruges, painted the picture in oil on an oak panel in 1434.
The woman stands hand in hand with a man from the Arnolfini family, merchants from Lucca, in Italy, who had members settled in Bruges. Behind the couple, a round mirror hangs on the wall of a furnished room.
Nearly six centuries after Jan van Eyck finished the Arnolfini Portrait, the green of her dress still holds its depth. Yet there is no rare pigment in it.


