Cool Stories About Art

Cool Stories About Art

The Painting That Obsessed Hitler Freud & Lenin

Freud kept it by his couch. Lenin above his bed. Hitler paid a fortune for it. By 1900, it hung in nearly every Berlin home. Discover the story of The Isle of the Dead.

Cool Stories About Art's avatar
Cool Stories About Art
Oct 30, 2025
∙ Paid
Header image for The Painting That Obsessed Hitler Freud & Lenin
Arnold Böcklin, “Isle of the Dead,” 1880, second version, Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York

This is a preview. Paid subscribers get the full story.


Look closely at this painting. A boat glides across still water toward a rocky islet. A ferryman rows. In front of him, a figure draped in white stands beside a coffin. Tall black cypresses rise from the island, and dark doorways open in the cliff.

Would you hang it in your living room?

Around 1900, almost every home in Berlin had a reproduction on the wall.

The painting is called “Isle of the Dead.” Three men with nothing in common lived with it too. Sigmund Freud, the inventor of psychoanalysis, kept an engraving of it in his consulting room. Vladimir Ilyich Lenin, the future leader of the Russian Revolution, slept beneath a reproduction. Adolf Hitler paid a fortune for one of the originals, painted by the Swiss artist Arnold Böcklin himself.

Why would a Jewish doctor, a communist revolutionary and the future Nazi dictator all want to live with the same image of death?

Each had his own reason. I’ll tell you all three stories, starting with the oldest man. But it all begins with a widow, in Florence, in the spring of 1880.

She pushes open the door of a Swiss painter’s studio and stops in front of an unfinished canvas he is painting for another client: a rocky islet on a dark sea, planted with cypresses that rise like black flames.

Her name is Marie Berna. Diphtheria has taken her husband, a wealthy financier, and she wants a painting like this one for herself alone, in his memory. With one addition.

Self Portrait - Arnold Böcklin
Arnold Böcklin, self portrait

The painter, Arnold Böcklin, is 52, and he knows death well. Three years earlier, in 1877, his daughter Maria died at seven months. He buried her in the English Cemetery, a short walk from his studio.

For Marie Berna, he adds a standing figure draped in white to the boat: a widow. At her feet, a white coffin.

With these two figures, the landscape takes on a new meaning. The boat is carrying a dead man to the afterlife, and the ferryman becomes Charon, who in Greek mythology ferries the dead to the underworld. Look at the doorways carved into the cliff: they are tombs.

Böcklin has found his image. He adds the same figures to the first canvas, then paints the scene again and again: between 1880 and 1886, five versions appear, each in its own light.

Arnold Böcklin: Isle of the Dead (version 1)
Arnold Böcklin, “Isle of the Dead,” 1880, first version, Kunstmuseum Basel

Böcklin calls it an “island of graves.” His Berlin dealer, Fritz Gurlitt, comes up with a stronger title, “Isle of the Dead,” and soon the image is selling as engravings, then as thousands of photographic prints, across Germany and far beyond.

The image reaches Vienna. Around 1900, the Habsburg capital is one of Europe’s great intellectual centers: Gustav Klimt paints there, Gustav Mahler conducts at the Opera, and a Jewish doctor in his forties, Sigmund Freud, is inventing psychoanalysis.


Freud and the Dream of the Island

Sigmund Freud photographed by Ludwig Grillich, around 1905.
Sigmund Freud photographed by Ludwig Grillich, around 1905

At 19 Berggasse, Freud sees his patients in a consulting room crowded with ancient statuettes. They lie on a couch covered with a Persian rug, and he lets them talk without interrupting, alert to whatever their dreams give away. On the wall by the couch hangs the Böcklin engraving.

He analyzes his own dreams, too. In one of them, the island appears: a cliff in the middle of the sea, painted in Böcklin’s style, with a man standing on the rock. Freud records this dream in “The Interpretation of Dreams,” which he publishes in 1899.

Freud then tries to work out who the man is. He thinks of a prisoner all of Europe is talking about: Captain Alfred Dreyfus. A Jewish officer in the French army, Dreyfus was convicted in 1894 of spying for Germany, a crime he did not commit. Since then, he has been serving his sentence on Devil’s Island, a remote penal colony off the coast of French Guiana.

In Freud’s dream, Böcklin’s island has become Dreyfus’s island.

Why Dreyfus? Because Freud, a Jew himself, sees antisemitism rising all over Europe. In Vienna itself, a politician named Karl Lueger became mayor in 1897 by railing against the Jews in his speeches.


Know someone who would love these stories? Give them a month or a year, with a note from you. 🎁

Give the stories


In March 1938, the German army marches into Vienna. Hitler annexes Austria, and the city’s Jews are hunted down. At 82, Freud reluctantly goes into exile. On June 4, he takes the train to London. His couch, his statuettes and Böcklin’s island go with him.

Now let’s go back to the painting.

Arnold Böcklin - Isle of the Dead (version 3)
Arnold Böcklin, “Isle of the Dead,” 1883, third version, Alte Nationalgalerie, Berlin

Look closely at the cliff on the right. Above the door of one of the tombs, Böcklin has carved two letters.

What You’ll Discover

  • The two letters carved into the cliff

  • The sixth island, which Böcklin never finished

  • Why Lenin was fascinated by the Isle of the Dead

  • What Hitler saw in the boat

  • The other island Böcklin painted: the Isle of the Living


200,000+ readers learn art the fun way.

Paid subscribers get the full story. You’ll also get:

  • 10 new stories / month

  • The full archive (150+ Art stories)

  • Your personal art guide. Comment, ask questions, DM me anytime

There’s only one person behind Cool Stories: me. Paid subscribers make it possible.

Less than a coffee a month. Cancel anytime.

Apple user? Subscribe at coolstoriesabout.art, not via the app. Apple adds 30% to the price.


This post is for paid subscribers

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2026 Cool Stories About Art · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for writing, podcasting, and media founders.