Carlo Crivelli: The Complete Story

Carlo Crivelli was a painter of the early Renaissance, born in Venice around 1430. He spent most of his career in the Marche, a region of central Italy on the Adriatic coast, and died around 1495, probably in the town of Ascoli Piceno.

The Annunciation, with Saint Emidius by Carlo Crivelli: Gabriel and Saint Emidius in a street, Mary in her room
Carlo Crivelli, The Annunciation, with Saint Emidius, 1486. National Gallery, London.

He painted only sacred scenes, in egg tempera, a paint made by binding pigment with egg yolk, and in raised gold, with sharp outlines, rich brocades and fruit. His best-known picture is The Annunciation of 1486, now in London, with a cucumber and an apple on its front ledge.

His signature hides a puzzle. In 1457 the courts of Venice sentenced him to six months in prison for abducting a sailor's wife, and he left the city. Yet decades later, far from Venice, he still signed his pictures as a Venetian.


Cool Stories About Art is a newsletter to learn art the fun way.

Join 200,000+ readers and get:

  • 10 new art stories / month

  • The entire archive of content (140+ articles)

  • Comment, ask questions, and chat with other readers


The Annunciation of 1486 is an altarpiece, a painting made to stand above a church altar. It shows the moment the angel Gabriel comes to tell Mary that she will bear the son of God, and Crivelli sets that moment in the street of a small Italian town.

Gabriel kneels in the street, outside a wall. Beyond it, Mary kneels at a prayer desk in a rich house, and a ray of light carrying the dove of the Holy Spirit comes down from the sky through a golden opening in the wall. In the town, only a child and a young man notice it.

Crivelli fills the house with detail. A carpet hangs over the loggia, an open gallery, a peacock stands on a ledge and a goldfinch sits in a cage. In the foreground, on a marble ledge along the bottom of the picture, lie an apple and a cucumber.

The picture was made for the church of the Santissima Annunziata in Ascoli Piceno, and it celebrates a piece of news. Ascoli lay in the Papal States, the lands ruled by the pope, and in 1482 Pope Sixtus IV granted the town a measure of self-government.

That news reached Ascoli on March 25, the feast of the Annunciation. The town therefore thanked the pope with the scene of that very day, and along the base of the picture run three coats of arms, the town's, the pope's and the bishop's.

The town's patron is in the picture too. Saint Emidius, the first bishop of Ascoli, kneels beside Gabriel with a model of the town balanced on his knee.

In this civic note of thanks, the cucumber is an odd guest. Crivelli never explained it, and the meaning given to it today depends on the apple lying beside it.

Leaving Venice for the Marche

Massa Fermana Altarpiece by Carlo Crivelli: Virgin and Child enthroned among four saints, a predella below, three gables
Carlo Crivelli, Massa Fermana Altarpiece, 1468. Church of Santi Lorenzo, Silvestro e Ruffino, Massa Fermana.

Carlo Crivelli reached Ascoli only after a long detour. It began in a family of Venetian painters, and after the trial his name next turns up across the Adriatic, in a town that is now in Croatia.


What You'll Discover

  • Why he left Venice behind.

  • Who paid for the gold.

  • How gold rises off a panel.

  • What the cucumber is doing there.

  • What he added to his name.

  • Who left him out of the story.


Read the rest of Carlo Crivelli's life, for free. Just leave your email and keep reading.


Subscribe for free to continue reading

Enter your email and get every post from Cool Stories About Art .